9. Kat Graham as Bonnie Bennett in The Vampire Diaries
While we’re on the subject of supernatural television shows centered largely around vampires, let’s not forget The Vampire Diaries’ resident witch! We’ve gotten to meet a number of Bonnie’s witchy relatives over the course of the series, including Buffy the Vampire Slayer alum Bianca Lawson as her fourth great-grandmother, but Bonnie herself is always our touchstone. Though Kat had appeared in shows ranging from Malcolm in the Middle to Hannah Montana beforehand, Bonnie is considered her breakout role.