"Home Births Are in Fact SAFE!"

There is a heated debate as to what kind of birth is best - is it home or hospital setting birth?

In Her Words

“Home Births Are in Fact SAFE!”

Passion fuels both sides of the issue

-Jennifer Lubell

newborn baby and motherJanita Pavelka, a 45-year-old mom from Oxford, Neb., had all four of her children at home and would do it again “in a heartbeat.”

“It was a wonderful experience; calm, peaceful, bonding for my husband and me. It’s the way birth was intended to be,” she said.

Mothers who choose to have their babies at home are very passionate about their choice – and will back up that choice vehemently with statistics and personal anecdotes. The reality in the United States, however, is that most women will choose to have their babies in a hospital setting. While some organizations such as the National Association of Nurse-Midwives support the right of women to choose home birth, provided they meet certain criteria, other groups strongly advocate giving birth in the hospital.

“Despite the rosy picture painted by home birth advocates, a seemingly normal labor and delivery can quickly become life-threatening for both the mother and baby,” claims the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists.

The home birth controversy recently made headlines when Janet Fraser, one of the most outspoken advocates of home births, had a baby girl who died of cardiac arrest during an unassisted home water birth in Australia.

As sad as this story is, many women in this country believe having babies at home is the safer option.

“If you consider that 95% of all world births are not born in hospitals, why are hospitals safer?” said Kitty Werner, of Waitsfield, Vt., who had both of her children at home. Unlike Fraser, Werner had the support of a midwife. In her opinion, “using experienced trained midwives is a just as safe, or than using a hospital.”

Homebirths are not endangered by the dangerous overuse of medical technology, “much of which has never been proven to be safe or effective as usual care. Birth is safe. Interference is risky,” asserts Jennifer Fargár, a certified birth doula and chairperson of the Georgia Friends of Midwives.

So many misconceptions about home births exist, “that ol’ granny midwives with no formal training assist. That all women who chose to give birth at home are some kind of granola crunching hippies, burning incense and chanting mantras. That’s it is messy, there’s blood everywhere. And that it’s dangerous.”

Valerie Christensen, who had three hospital births and one home birth, challenged her obstetrician’s concerns that too many things could go wrong with a home birth. So many problems are caused by hospital intervention – “inductions, slowed labor from epidurals or narcotics, fetal distress from pitocin,” Christensen had argued.

Still, others feel that the hospital is the safest place to have a child in any circumstances.

Kara Glad, who lost a child to preterm birth at 24 weeks after an emergency C-section, strongly favors delivering babies at a hospital that has a neonatal intensive care unit.

“You never know what can happen at any time and it is such a miracle to have a healthy baby, so I feel you need to have all your resources available in case of an emergency arises. I know several friends who carried to term and their babies still needed to visit the NICU,” she said.

Jennifer Lubell is a healthcare reporter in Washington, D.C.

follow BettyConfidential on... Pinterest

Read More About...

0 thoughts on “"Home Births Are in Fact SAFE!"

  1. whenever i pop a bun out of the oven, i’d want to do it in a hospital setting with trained professionals at my side. i dont pay millions in hospital bills and taxes to put myself, my baby, and husband at risk! wtf, seriously. hospitals all the way!

  2. I think the hospital is best as well, since Mother Nature can be unpredictable. No one ever knows if the baby is born breech, or if forceps are necessary. There is too much room for era in my book. I knew a woman who started to go into contraction and then couldn’t push the baby out, the baby suffocated and died. Terrorible, but I would put my baby and me in in a safe place first, other wise suffer the consequences.

  3. It angers me when I hear about women putting their own interests before what is best for their baby. I have heard of way too many babies dying in a home birth or major complications that put the baby in too much risk. People have to stop being so selfish, and concentrate on what is best for their newborn.

  4. With hospital-borne infections and complications that are sometimes CAUSED by doctors and hospital staff (I worked in a hospital for over four years, and I’ve seen it happen), I can understand why some women would prefer to have a more natural birth experience at home or in a birthing center. Women should have the choice to give birth any way that they see fit, as long as their obstetrician feels that the birth plan will not endanger the baby or the mother. I had considered home birth when I was pregnant, but I had to have an emergency c-section, and I’m too nervous about VBAC to risk it outside of a hospital, but just because it’s not right for me doesn’t mean that it’s not right for other women who don’t have high-risk pregnancies.

Leave a Reply

top of page jump to top