Why Jaycee Dugard Stayed

Experts tell us why Jaycee Dugard stayed with the kidnapper so long.
1 / 2

Why Jaycee Dugard Stayed

Experts explain to Betty Confidential why the kidnap victim stayed for 18 years with the man who stole her from her family

-Jane Farrell

Jaycee Dugard

The case of Jaycee Dugard, the kidnap victim who was held by her captor for 18 years, has drawn worldwide attention for the length of her imprisonment and for the fact that she has had two children with the man who shut her off from everything she knew. Paul Garrido, 58, and his wife Nancy, 54, have been arrested for the crime.

But why didn’t Jaycee, held in a backyard compound in California between the ages of 11 and 29, simply climb over the wall and run away? The answer to that question lies in the complicated, ambiguous relationship that forms between kidnapper and victim, experts say.

As hard as it might be for outsiders to believe, the kidnapper in a case like Jaycee’s in all likelihood eventually becomes “a kind of family for her,” Paula Fass, Ph.D., Margaret Byrne Professor of History at the University of California, Berkeley, tells Betty Confidential. Police have said that Jaycee was forced to live in a rudimentary collection of sheds and tents in Garrido’s backyard in Antioch, Calif., where conditions were similar to a campsite. Even though she was locked in a soundproof shed for periods of time, in Jaycee’s view, Fass says, “[Garrido] provided her with food and caretaking … He didn’t kill her.”

Fass also points to Jaycee’s age in explaining how Garrido came to have such power over her. “This was a young girl, 11 years old, who no doubt was told she was no longer wanted by her family,” says Fass, author of Kidnapped: Child Abduction in America. And according to former FBI profiler Clint Van Zandt, “a kidnap victim is told that if she tries to escape,” she’ll be killed. In addition, he said, kidnappers threaten to kill the child’s family or a pet. “I don’t think any of us can understand the trauma that this little girl went [through],” Van Zandt said on the Today Show. To further narrow her view, Jaycee was kept from anything like radio or TV that would tell her what was going on the world.


follow BettyConfidential on... Pinterest


Read More About...
Related Articles...

0 thoughts on “Why Jaycee Dugard Stayed

  1. deborah says:

    I want to know WHY the ass**** kidnappers took this child!

  2. Nannypoo1 says:

    His wife must be a real number, too. Why would any woman in her right mind stay with a man who has another lover living at the same residence and that over has children for that man. There’s a lot to this story that has not come out yet. I will be interested in learning more.

  3. blondeelicious says:

    It just breaks my heart that she will spend the rest of her life dealing with the deep issues that this situation cause within her. There is so much work to be done to try to undo the damage that this must have caused. My heart goes out to her, her daughters and her family.

  4. stefslade says:

    Sad and yet in this rare case, Jaycee and her children are survivors. Here is a video I just completed for Mista Majah P inspired by an 11 year old Jamaican girl, Ananda Dean, who was brutally raped and murdered on her way home from her Jamaican Elementary school. I hope it will be used in classrooms and schools to bring awareness to parents, teachers and caregivers to ‘Keep an eye on your children’ and make child safety both on ground and online a priority. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=on6CDGYwRw8

Leave a Reply

top of page jump to top